Chris (conjurdude) wrote,

  • Mood:

Thank you jeebus

Roy Moore has been removed from his position as Chief Justice of Alabama's Supreme Court for overstepping his bounds and defying a federal court order to remove his 2.5 granite idol to the ten commandments.

As part of my quiet jubilation, I would like to quote from an individual on the message board explaining exactly why this was necessary (and backing it up with points of law). "spatula" wrote:

Nobody's claimed that the Constitution says people can't express their religion on state property. This is a red herring.

What we are saying is that it is not permitted for the state to endorse a particular religion to the exclusion of others or of non-religion. Once again, the facts:

1. Roy Moore is an agent of the state and is therefore accountable to uphold the Constitution while acting in the capacity of his office (Everson v Board of Ed; US Constitution Article 6, Amendment 14).

2. The Constitution forbids actions respecting the establishment of a religion by the government. (Illinois ex rel. McCollum v. Board of Educ; Amendment 1).

3. Roy Moore had a specific religious intent in placing his monument in the rotunda of the state judicial building. (Lemon v Kurtzman)

4. Roy Moore was in the administrative charge of controlling what could and could not be placed in the rotunda of the courthouse, and forbade the placement of other items by the public (Everson v Board of Ed again and Widmar v Vincent)

Ergo, Roy Moore violated the establishment clause of the First Amendment by placing a religious monument on display with religious intentions acting in his official capacity in a forum that was not generally open to the public. He was very clearly out of line.

Wakka Wakka Hell Yeah!


(Yes, I'm gloating. Deal with it.)

  • (no subject)

    So, I'd spent the last month and some change worried that I'd done irreparable harm to a friendship that really does mean the world to me; I'm so…

  • Oh, hi there!

    Hey, there, LJ, I didn't see you come in... So yeah. It's been a looooooong time since my last update. TL;DR, I'm in California now. I relocated,…

  • (no subject)

    I miss California tremendously. I'm working on getting back there permanently. That is all (for now).

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded